|
Soldier Pile Wall
|
Bored Pile Wall
|
Soilmix/Slurry Wall
|
Advantages
|
Soldier pile and lagging walls are the most inexpensive systems compared to other retaining walls. They are also very easy and fast to construct
|
Low cost and speed of construction for temporary and permanent retaining walls and soil support
|
Excellent resistance to contaminated groundwater. They have abilityto adapt to ground movements such as earthquakes
|
Methodology
|
Constructed using piles timber infill panels
(timber, steel or concrete)
|
Series of bored piles installed relatively close together with shotcrete arches
|
Steel or precast concrete elements placed in fluid soilmix / slurry
|
Construction
|
Establishment
|
50-60T self erecting hydraulic drilling rigs and handling crane
|
50-60T self erecting hydraulic drilling rigs, handling crane and concrete pumps
|
50T crane + grab / CSM, handling crane / grout plant with screw feed silos, high pressure pumps
|
Piling productivity
|
16m deep - 300mm square piles @ 18No/day
|
16m deep - 600dia @ 4No/day in soft material including a 3m soft rock socket depth. Detailed production rates
|
16m deep by 800mm wide @ 20-50m3/day of completed wall per rig per day
|
Materials to site
|
Concrete, reinforcement cages, steel or precast concrete panels
|
Concrete, reinforcement cages
|
Cement, bentonite, steel or precast concrete panels
|
Work face access
|
Plant & Materials delivery
|
Plant & Materials delivery
|
Plant, materials and pipeline delivery of slurry
|
Noise
|
Yes, if driven sections
|
Machine only
|
Machine only
|
Vibration
|
Yes, if driven sections
|
No
|
No
|
Spoil
|
Dependant on installation method
|
100% nett volume
|
30%-80% Nett volume
|
Product
|
Wall Movement
|
Ground unsupported allowing relaxation prior placement of panels and backfilling Stiffness depends on structural section
and backfill compaction
|
Ground unsupported allowing relaxation prior to concrete
Finished product stiff
|
Ground supported with stiffness dependant on steel section.
Precast panels can increase stiffness.
|
Watertightness
|
Permeable with no groundwater control
below excavation. Seepages long term
|
Permeable until shotcrete in place with no
groundwater control below. Seepages long term
|
Good temporary performance due to
replacement with CB slurry but some seepages
|
Connections
|
Numerous connection options dependant on materials used
|
Drilled and grouted bars into piles, shear
and bending capacity possible
|
Welded to steel sections, shear & bending capacity possible.
|
Durability
|
Conventional concrete in the ground
design or sacrificial steel thickness given
long term seepage potential
|
Conventional concrete in ground design
|
Sacrificial thickness of steel and internal
lining wall for long-term groundwater seepage
|
Load Capacity
|
Capacity can be enhanced by increasing the length of piles.
|
Capacity can be enhanced by increasing the length of some piles.
|
Capacity limited by penetration of steel beams
|